canon s3 is vs panasonic fz-50

Discussion in 'Panasonic Lumix' started by gA, Feb 8, 2007.

  1. gA

    gA Guest

    These 2 seem my only choices if I want
    - swivel LCD
    - movies

    However, I am concerned about low-light picture quality and
    overexposed flash photography. Any recommendations, comments?
    Thank you in advance.
    - gA
     
    gA, Feb 8, 2007
    #1
    1. Advertising

  2. gA

    sally Guest

    gA <> wrote in news:MOMyh.917244$R63.724425@pd7urf1no:
    > However, I am concerned about low-light picture quality and
    > overexposed flash photography. Any recommendations, comments?


    Due to the small image sensors, none of the 12X zoom cameras do really well
    in low-light situations. Do you really need 12X? If not, there are many
    better cameras for low-light.
     
    sally, Feb 9, 2007
    #2
    1. Advertising

  3. gA

    gA Guest

    Thanks, Sally. I don't need 12x zoom but I WILL NOT give up my 2
    requiremnts of swivel LCD and movies. By the way, I just went to
    the camera shop and looked at both cameras: I don't like the
    'feel' and the bulky size of the FZ-50.

    I was told by the salesman that (rumors only!) Canon is coming out
    with a new model, perhaps an S4, featuring a wider angle and
    bigger processor. That would surely do it for me!

    Are there any web sites where I could get the scoops on newer
    model coming out?
    - gA

    sally wrote:
    > gA <> wrote in news:MOMyh.917244$R63.724425@pd7urf1no:
    >> However, I am concerned about low-light picture quality and
    >> overexposed flash photography. Any recommendations, comments?

    >
    > Due to the small image sensors, none of the 12X zoom cameras do really well
    > in low-light situations. Do you really need 12X? If not, there are many
    > better cameras for low-light.
     
    gA, Feb 9, 2007
    #3
  4. gA

    ASAAR Guest

    On Fri, 09 Feb 2007 02:01:06 GMT, gA wrote:

    > Thanks, Sally. I don't need 12x zoom but I WILL NOT give up my 2
    > requiremnts of swivel LCD and movies. By the way, I just went to
    > the camera shop and looked at both cameras: I don't like the
    > 'feel' and the bulky size of the FZ-50.


    Canon's A630/A640 have swiveling, rotating LCDs and movies. They
    won't fit in a shirt pocket but are a good deal more compact than
    the S3. Anything else common to the S3 and FZ-50 that you won't
    give up but haven't yet mentioned?


    > I was told by the salesman that (rumors only!) Canon is coming out
    > with a new model, perhaps an S4, featuring a wider angle and
    > bigger processor. That would surely do it for me!


    That's probably more guesstimate than rumor. Canon periodically
    upgrades their cameras, but occasionally there's a loooong gap, such
    as the one between the G6 and G7. If the S4 is similarly delayed,
    you'll be waiting quite a while for it.


    > Are there any web sites where I could get the scoops on newer
    > model coming out?


    Dpreview.com and probably most other decent camera review
    websites. They don't usually have full reviews until the cameras
    have been selling for a while, but they will have something on new
    models before they're available, sometimes many months before
    release. Check their News and the News archive. If you compare the
    date of product announcements with the comments in reviews of older
    Canon models (such as the S2 and S1, not just the S3) you may see a
    pattern of how much advance notice you'll get, and might assume that
    it will be the same for the S4 IS.
     
    ASAAR, Feb 9, 2007
    #4
  5. gA

    gA Guest

    Thanks for the good information, ASAAR, the site you mentioned
    seems very good. I checked the A640 and I was surprised to see how
    well the features compare to the S3's. Although I don't need 12x
    zoom, I would like to have more than 4x offered by the A640. My S1
    spoiled me with 10x, but 8-10 would be nice. Other features
    lacking for me in the A640 are the EVF, IS, photo-stitching, and
    a faster shutter.

    I hope to find what I need before August, and I will be on the
    lookout for anything new and educative information I can find.
    Cheers, - gA

    ASAAR wrote:
    > On Fri, 09 Feb 2007 02:01:06 GMT, gA wrote:
    >
    >> Thanks, Sally. I don't need 12x zoom but I WILL NOT give up my 2
    >> requiremnts of swivel LCD and movies. By the way, I just went to
    >> the camera shop and looked at both cameras: I don't like the
    >> 'feel' and the bulky size of the FZ-50.

    >
    > Canon's A630/A640 have swiveling, rotating LCDs and movies. They
    > won't fit in a shirt pocket but are a good deal more compact than
    > the S3. Anything else common to the S3 and FZ-50 that you won't
    > give up but haven't yet mentioned?
    >
    >
    >> I was told by the salesman that (rumors only!) Canon is coming out
    >> with a new model, perhaps an S4, featuring a wider angle and
    >> bigger processor. That would surely do it for me!

    >
    > That's probably more guesstimate than rumor. Canon periodically
    > upgrades their cameras, but occasionally there's a loooong gap, such
    > as the one between the G6 and G7. If the S4 is similarly delayed,
    > you'll be waiting quite a while for it.
    >
    >
    >> Are there any web sites where I could get the scoops on newer
    >> model coming out?

    >
    > Dpreview.com and probably most other decent camera review
    > websites. They don't usually have full reviews until the cameras
    > have been selling for a while, but they will have something on new
    > models before they're available, sometimes many months before
    > release. Check their News and the News archive. If you compare the
    > date of product announcements with the comments in reviews of older
    > Canon models (such as the S2 and S1, not just the S3) you may see a
    > pattern of how much advance notice you'll get, and might assume that
    > it will be the same for the S4 IS.
    >
     
    gA, Feb 9, 2007
    #5
  6. gA

    ASAAR Guest

    On Fri, 09 Feb 2007 04:00:06 GMT, gA wrote:

    > Thanks for the good information, ASAAR, the site you mentioned
    > seems very good. I checked the A640 and I was surprised to see how
    > well the features compare to the S3's. Although I don't need 12x
    > zoom, I would like to have more than 4x offered by the A640. My S1
    > spoiled me with 10x, but 8-10 would be nice. Other features
    > lacking for me in the A640 are the EVF, IS, photo-stitching, and
    > a faster shutter.


    You're welcome. I agree about the lack of an EVF as I've gotten
    used to and like the one in my Fuji, but the optical VF has some
    advantages. It won't be bothered by bright sun, and it can help
    extend battery life. With high capacity NiMH batteries, you could
    probably take about 1,600 shots per charge, unless you use the LCD a
    lot or start using the flash.

    The A640, like all of Canon's Powershots that I'm aware of, has
    built-in support for panoramics in the camera (Stitch Assist). Is
    your reference to "photo-stitching" about something else? I'm also
    not sure what you mean by a faster shutter than the A640 has. The
    shutter speed can go to 1/2,500th sec. Did you mean the burst rate
    for multiple shots isn't fast enough, or the shutter's lag time is
    too long? For a full shutter press, it's 0.6 sec, and after
    prefocusing, the remaining lag time is either 0.08 sec. (when using
    the LCD) or 0.05 sec. (when you use the optical viewfinder). Both
    of those lag times are pretty quick.
     
    ASAAR, Feb 9, 2007
    #6
  7. gA

    Paul Allen Guest

    On Thu, 08 Feb 2007 21:42:04 GMT
    gA <> wrote:

    > These 2 seem my only choices if I want
    > - swivel LCD
    > - movies
    >
    > However, I am concerned about low-light picture quality and
    > overexposed flash photography. Any recommendations, comments?


    I have the older FZ30 and like it a lot. It weighs about what
    my old OM2n did with its 50mm 1/1.8 lens, and is only slightly
    longer. I have handled the older Canon S2, and prefer the feel
    of the FZ30. The guy whose S2 I handled loved it.

    There are very few point and shoots with decent low-light
    performance because the sensors are so small. Both of the
    cameras you mention will suffer in low light. Fuji has models
    with somewhat better than average noise characteristics, but
    they may not match your two key criteria.

    I don't use the built-in flash if I can help it. Unless a camera
    can cut off the shutter when it sees enough light coming back
    from the subject, you'll always have exposure challenges with
    the flash. You can get around the inverse-square law with exposure
    compensation, but you still have flat images with no shadows.
    Boring.

    I don't buy still cameras to take movies with, although I will
    occasionally shoot a movie clip. The FZ30 does fine for what
    I need, and the FZ50 appears to simply add a 16:9 movie format.
    The S3 is said to have a good movie mode.

    The S3 has the same size LCD as the FZ50, but with lower resolution.
    It swivels to the side so it's less likely to conflict with a tripod.

    When I was comparing the S3 with the FZ30, the deciding factors
    were the FZ30's slightly better optics and the manual zoom and
    focus rings on the lens. The S3's smaller size and price were
    attractive but not decisive. The S3 uses regular AA batteries,
    while the FZ50 uses a Li-ion battery with a fiddly little proprietary
    charger. I've gotten used to dealing with the funny battery on my
    FZ30, but I still worry about misplacing the charger on trips.

    Good luck!

    Paul Allen
     
    Paul Allen, Feb 9, 2007
    #7
  8. gA

    gA Guest

    Thanks for taking the time to write those helpful comments, Paul.
    I hope that that salesman was right with the rumors...
    Cheers, - gA

    Paul Allen wrote:
    > On Thu, 08 Feb 2007 21:42:04 GMT
    > gA <> wrote:
    >
    >> These 2 seem my only choices if I want
    >> - swivel LCD
    >> - movies
    >>
    >> However, I am concerned about low-light picture quality and
    >> overexposed flash photography. Any recommendations, comments?

    >
    > I have the older FZ30 and like it a lot. It weighs about what
    > my old OM2n did with its 50mm 1/1.8 lens, and is only slightly
    > longer. I have handled the older Canon S2, and prefer the feel
    > of the FZ30. The guy whose S2 I handled loved it.
    >
    > There are very few point and shoots with decent low-light
    > performance because the sensors are so small. Both of the
    > cameras you mention will suffer in low light. Fuji has models
    > with somewhat better than average noise characteristics, but
    > they may not match your two key criteria.
    >
    > I don't use the built-in flash if I can help it. Unless a camera
    > can cut off the shutter when it sees enough light coming back
    > from the subject, you'll always have exposure challenges with
    > the flash. You can get around the inverse-square law with exposure
    > compensation, but you still have flat images with no shadows.
    > Boring.
    >
    > I don't buy still cameras to take movies with, although I will
    > occasionally shoot a movie clip. The FZ30 does fine for what
    > I need, and the FZ50 appears to simply add a 16:9 movie format.
    > The S3 is said to have a good movie mode.
    >
    > The S3 has the same size LCD as the FZ50, but with lower resolution.
    > It swivels to the side so it's less likely to conflict with a tripod.
    >
    > When I was comparing the S3 with the FZ30, the deciding factors
    > were the FZ30's slightly better optics and the manual zoom and
    > focus rings on the lens. The S3's smaller size and price were
    > attractive but not decisive. The S3 uses regular AA batteries,
    > while the FZ50 uses a Li-ion battery with a fiddly little proprietary
    > charger. I've gotten used to dealing with the funny battery on my
    > FZ30, but I still worry about misplacing the charger on trips.
    >
    > Good luck!
    >
    > Paul Allen
     
    gA, Feb 12, 2007
    #8
    1. Advertising

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

It takes just 2 minutes to sign up (and it's free!). Just click the sign up button to choose a username and then you can ask your own questions on the forum.
Similar Threads
  1. Nihal

    Panasonic Vs Kodak Vs Minolta Vs Canon

    Nihal, Dec 2, 2004, in forum: Panasonic Lumix
    Replies:
    24
    Views:
    2,986
    Chuck
    Dec 5, 2004
  2. sam

    Super Zooms Panasonic FZ7 vs Canon S3

    sam, Jun 23, 2006, in forum: Panasonic Lumix
    Replies:
    2
    Views:
    368
  3. ace in indiana
    Replies:
    3
    Views:
    537
    Richard Crowley
    Oct 25, 2004
  4. J. Clarke
    Replies:
    0
    Views:
    365
    J. Clarke
    May 12, 2006
  5. RichA
    Replies:
    4
    Views:
    407
    RichA
    Feb 15, 2012
Loading...

Share This Page