Nikon D50 versus Lumix FZ30

Discussion in 'Panasonic Lumix' started by Sandy Bloom, Ph.D., Feb 5, 2006.

  1. I just purchased the D50 and can try it out for 30 days from Walmart
    ($665.00). This is the only place I found where I can actually try out the
    camera at home, put it though its paces, and truly see if it is for me. So
    far, I like it. But I can't compare it personally to other cameras, see
    below.

    I have 4 questions: (Thanks for your patience)

    1. Any comments about the higher ISO noise rep on the FZ30 compared to
    the D50? I can't try out the FZ30 for free (restocking fee upon return).
    The FZ30 has always attracted me for the 8 megapixels and the one lens large
    Leica Zoom with stabilization, but I want to use it for a variety of things,
    including sports stop action and available light (higher ISOs).

    2. The D50 kit lens (G-ED) is reviewed to be not as good as the D70 kit
    lens (D-ED), different focal ranges also. Would you care to comment on the
    visual difference between these lenses? Would the "common" eye be able to
    notice any difference? Again, I cannot try out the D-ED lens, unless
    Walmart will order it for me. Even then I may then not be able to return it
    if specially ordered.

    3. I've struggled with considering the D200, mostly for its 10 megapixel
    size. Other attractive issues are the coupled metering with older Nikon AI
    lenses and very high fps continuous mode. Frankly, the price of the kit is
    $2000.00, including the better D-ED lens (18 to 70), and I just can't
    justify that expenditure now as an amateur. Certainly my wife can't also,
    but she is open to it just the same, (God bless her). I'm the stalwart one
    who is very money conscious.

    4. The D70s has the better lens, but I think the body of the D50 has all
    I will need. I could order the D50 body and the better Nikon lens, but the
    price is just a couple hundred bucks from the D70s kit price of $1200.00
    bucks list.

    If I knew the FZ30 would perform well under higher ISO's, I'd opt for that
    in a heartbeat, and never look back.

    Thanks for considering these questions. I will gladly pay you guys for the
    "therapy" you will give me here (wink).

    Regards,

    Sandy
     
    Sandy Bloom, Ph.D., Feb 5, 2006
    #1
    1. Advertising

  2. Sandy Bloom, Ph.D.

    LoLo Guest

    ...
    > 1. Any comments about the higher ISO noise rep on the FZ30 compared to
    > the D50? I can't try out the FZ30 for free (restocking fee upon return).
    > The FZ30 has always attracted me for the 8 megapixels and the one lens
    > large
    > Leica Zoom with stabilization, but I want to use it for a variety of
    > things,
    > including sports stop action and available light (higher ISOs).
    >
    > 2. The D50 kit lens (G-ED) is reviewed to be not as good as the D70
    > kit
    > lens (D-ED), different focal ranges also. Would you care to comment on
    > the
    > visual difference between these lenses? Would the "common" eye be able to
    > notice any difference? Again, I cannot try out the D-ED lens, unless
    > Walmart will order it for me. Even then I may then not be able to return
    > it
    > if specially ordered.
    >

    I was real close to buying the Lumix but for just a little more money I
    think I got a much better and more expandable system.

    I've seen three, maybe four Nikon "kit" lens'es offered with the D50. Which
    one came with the Walmart package ?

    Here's some advice that I got and applied and it saved me a bunch: Call
    Dell.com's catalog sales 1-800 number. Even though they are not on their
    web site, they will sell you D50 and D70 kits and will almost match the web
    site prices of places like www.royalcamera.com - you do have to be patient
    and spell things carefully for the order taker in India. And they will take
    time while you hold to surf over to the comparison shop site that you must
    mention.

    In stock near Atlanta, GA. I got the D50 kit that came with the 28-80 lens
    (which I sold on ebay for $50). It's the worst of those offered. Total
    delivered price back at Christmas time was under $520 for the D50 kit.


    By the way, I still don't believe it but it happened: At the same time I
    bought a 512 mb mem card for the camera. Worked the process to send it back
    since I changed my mind and bought a 1Gb card locally. They credited me the
    full price including shipping, did Not apply any restock fee, and told me to
    keep the memory card.
     
    LoLo, Feb 5, 2006
    #2
    1. Advertising

  3. Sandy Bloom, Ph.D.

    Johnny Mo Guest

    FYI, there's good resources on the internet for D50 and more general photo
    related items:

    nikonians.com
    photo.net
    nikoncafe.com

    As an old and many years inactive Nikon SLR film guy I've had a lot to learn
    about DSLR even though I'm an experienced digital P&S'er.

    I read through those sites and made good use of ebay and the buy / sell
    forums on the above sites to get a collection of lenses.

    I'm using these with my D50 and N8008s:

    18-70mm f/3.5-4.5G ED-IF AF-S DX Zoom Nikkor (wonderful, but won't work on
    my 35mm full frame film camera)
    The focusing motor is one of those magic ultrasonic things - and you can
    manual focus whenever you feel like it, nothing to push or set.

    28-70 f/2.8 AF Sigma (1st generation AF, old/heavy and fast enough to do
    extremely well in no flash situations)

    50mm 1.8 AF Nikkor (made in Japan, good fast walk-around and portrait.
    Small enough to get lost in the bag. Best technical quality of all the
    lenses.

    70-300mm f/4-5.6D ED AF Zoom Nikkor (don't believe the somewhat negative
    lens reports, by whatever magic the pictures from it are a delight)


    The great thing about Nikon lenses is if you stay with the good ones you can
    sell them months or years later with a very low overall cost of ownership.
    The great thing about the D50 is it will use most all Nikon AF lenses.

    The new 18-200 Nikkor is generating a lot of interest but will be out of my
    price range for a long time.
     
    Johnny Mo, Feb 5, 2006
    #3
  4. Sandy Bloom, Ph.D.

    RichA Guest

    Why not buy a Pentax for $599 (kit lens incl.) then supplement with one
    of those
    18-200mm zooms from Sigma or Tamron?
    -Rich
     
    RichA, Feb 5, 2006
    #4
  5. "RichA" <> wrote in message
    news:...
    > Why not buy a Pentax for $599 (kit lens incl.) then supplement with one
    > of those
    > 18-200mm zooms from Sigma or Tamron?
    > -Rich
    >


    Which model specifically is this Pentax? What is the kit lens like, and are
    Tamron lenses of decent quality?

    Sandy
     
    Sandy Bloom, Ph.D., Feb 6, 2006
    #5
  6. Sandy Bloom, Ph.D.

    Tony Polson Guest

    "Sandy Bloom, Ph.D." <> wrote:
    >
    >Which model specifically is this Pentax? What is the kit lens like, and are
    >Tamron lenses of decent quality?


    The camera is probably the Pentax *ist DL2. It's a very good camera,
    with excellent image quality from the 6.1 MP sensor. The Pentax kit
    lens is very good - it is far superior to the kit lenses sold with
    Canon DSLRs, for example.

    Tamron make some excellent lenses, however a consumer priced lens with
    a zoom range of 18-200mm is not likely to be optically one of their
    best. The same comments apply to the Sigma lens of similar focal
    length range, however the Tamron is likely to be better made.
     
    Tony Polson, Feb 6, 2006
    #6
    1. Advertising

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

It takes just 2 minutes to sign up (and it's free!). Just click the sign up button to choose a username and then you can ask your own questions on the forum.
Similar Threads
  1. Steve
    Replies:
    3
    Views:
    374
    [BnH]
    Oct 9, 2005
  2. Jay

    Lumix FZ30 RAW Format

    Jay, Jan 19, 2006, in forum: Panasonic Lumix
    Replies:
    7
    Views:
    604
    techie
    Jan 20, 2006
  3. Al Bogner

    Looking for Lumix FZ30 rawfile

    Al Bogner, Sep 2, 2005, in forum: Panasonic Lumix
    Replies:
    0
    Views:
    261
    Al Bogner
    Sep 2, 2005
  4. Graham Archer

    Panasonic Lumix FZ30 V Fuji Finepix S9500 (S9000)

    Graham Archer, Sep 4, 2005, in forum: Panasonic Lumix
    Replies:
    21
    Views:
    676
    David J Taylor
    Sep 6, 2005
  5. gfh

    panasonic Lumix DMC-FZ30

    gfh, Dec 24, 2005, in forum: Panasonic Lumix
    Replies:
    1
    Views:
    259
    David J Taylor
    Dec 24, 2005
Loading...

Share This Page