Converting MiniDV "LP" (1.5hr tapes) to DVD+-R ????

Discussion in 'Amateur Video Production' started by Gene, Feb 1, 2007.

  1. Gene

    Gene Guest

    Good day, all.

    What is the current state-of-the-art to:
    Take a 1.5hr LP mode MiniDV tape that was recorded on a Sony
    camcorder and copy/convert it to a DVD+R or DVD-R having the maximum
    quality?

    I have found that getting from a "1" hour MiniDV (SP) mode is quite
    easy - zero problems using a PC or set-top DVR to create DVD-R and DVD+R.
    Most software & set-top DVR boxes do this without a problem.

    My problem is the 1.5 hour LP MiniDV mode - which is the only mode that
    I want to shoot in. (Most folks are unaware that the QUALITY of a SP (1 hr)
    and a LP (1.5 hr) is 100% the "same" - the bits are identical. In the
    old analog world, the LP mode was of less quality because the tape moved
    more slowly.
    In the digital world, tape speed does not matter. Slow digital tape speed
    could cause more drop-outs,
    and be more difficult to read - but the dots and dashes are the same, so the
    quality is the same.)

    Assuming that my Sony MiniDV camcorders all record and play back the 1.5 hr
    LP
    mode the same as if I were filming in the SP 1hr mode - naturally I want to
    shoot
    for 1.5hrs before having to change to a new tape. Incidentally, all of my
    D8 Sony
    camcorders will shoot and replay at the LP 1.5hr mode as well as the later
    MiniDV
    camcorders, you just get a slightly less quality product.


    So here is the QUESTION:)

    What specific hardware and/or software do I need to copy a 1.5hr LP mode
    MiniDV or
    1.5hr LP mode Digital-8 tape "DIRECTLY" onto inexpensive DVD-R or DVD+R
    media for replay
    on most DVD player boxes connected to a TV? Another way to ask the question
    is: Given the current technology, how do you copy a 1.5hr MiniDV tape onto
    a DVD-+R
    in REAL TIME and get the MAXIMUM quality possible? What specific hardware
    and/or software
    make & models do I need to purchase to do the above?

    THANKS,
    Gene
     
    Gene, Feb 1, 2007
    #1
    1. Advertisements

  2. "Gene" wrote ...
    Most people who record in LP mode come here crying
    and regretting the decision. Good luck. You will need it.
    I have significant doubts that your experiement will go
    as well as you think.
    You need a DVD recorder with firewire input.
    I got an email from Geeks today selling them for ~$60
    If you record in real-time to DVD in the "normal" mode
    (2 hours), there really isn't any range of "quality". It is what
    it is.
    I am quite happy with the several LiteOn DVD recorders I
    have bought at Costco. <$100
     
    Richard Crowley, Feb 2, 2007
    #2
    1. Advertisements

  3. Gene

    Gene Guest

    Thanks, Richard.

    I have a Liteon 5005 with all the mods:), a new Sony GX330, and a
    Panasonic ES20. The ES20 has what is known as "Flexible Recording"
    which lets me select 1.5 hours, the other two are the standard
    1, 2 hr, etc. mode. The ES20 hangs (freezes) far too often, and
    the other two create DVDs that only use a portion of the DVD-+R.
    Unless you completely fill up the DVD, you are not getting the
    best possible quality.

    Here is my ideal set-up, a dedicated PC that:
    - has two quality DVD burners
    - software that will simultaneously burn two DVD-R disc
    in real-time as it reads the MiniDV tape via firewire.
    - chapters generated automatically ~ every 5 or 6 minutes
    - the software will write the ~ 95 minutes of tape onto the two
    DVD-Rs, filling each to within 95%+ of DVD capacity.
    - the software will finalize both DVDs, open the DVD burner
    doors, and rewind the MiniDV at EOT.

    It sounds so simple. Just insert two blank DVD-Rs, place in a
    MiniDV tape, and start a program (or batch file) and come back
    in 1.5 hours to a finished product with maximum quality and chapters.
    Unfortunately, I can't find a specific program (or programs) that will do
    this without operator intervention.

    And while I'm wishing: I REALLY just want a camcorder that will
    write an hour of DV quality to a "LARGE" DVD-R disc - not those junky
    little 30 minute ones. Imaging, writing an hour or more to super inexpensive
    media, and never having to go to a PC or set-top box:)

    gene
     
    Gene, Feb 2, 2007
    #3
    1. Advertisements

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments (here). After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.