Nikon 17-35 f2.8 makes whining noise...

Anybody come across this before. The lens is quiet enough on a short
adjustment of the AF, but if focussing from, say, close up to infinity
then I can hear a nasty whine. It's especially pronounced when hunting
for focus and the motor is changing direction. Only had it a month,
and didn't notice it at first, but having not used it for a while, the
noise is now there and wouldn't seem normal for "Silent Wave". Also
this is the first AF-S Nikkor I've had so don't know if it's typical.

Grateful for any comments.

Call me Ishmael

 

In article <140920051329071193%>, says...
> Anybody come across this before. The lens is quiet enough on a short
> adjustment of the AF, but if focussing from, say, close up to infinity
> then I can hear a nasty whine. It's especially pronounced when hunting
> for focus and the motor is changing direction. Only had it a month,
> and didn't notice it at first, but having not used it for a while, the
> noise is now there and wouldn't seem normal for "Silent Wave". Also
> this is the first AF-S Nikkor I've had so don't know if it's typical.

No, it's certainly not normal for AF-S lenses. I've got 3 of them and
none of them make that kind of noise - in use they are totally silent.

But then again, it's a Nikon lens and with their quality control
recently, anything's possible. And if you're planning on having it
repaired, look forward to Nikon taking bloody weeks to fix it, too :-((

--
Neil Barker

 

Neil Barker <> verbally sodomised in
news:MPG.1d926cb8c83a3dea98987c@127.0.0.1:

> In article <140920051329071193%>, says...
>> Anybody come across this before. The lens is quiet enough on a short
>> adjustment of the AF, but if focussing from, say, close up to infinity
>> then I can hear a nasty whine. It's especially pronounced when hunting
>> for focus and the motor is changing direction. Only had it a month,
>> and didn't notice it at first, but having not used it for a while, the
>> noise is now there and wouldn't seem normal for "Silent Wave". Also
>> this is the first AF-S Nikkor I've had so don't know if it's typical.
>
> No, it's certainly not normal for AF-S lenses. I've got 3 of them and
> none of them make that kind of noise - in use they are totally silent.
>
> But then again, it's a Nikon lens and with their quality control
> recently, anything's possible. And if you're planning on having it
> repaired, look forward to Nikon taking bloody weeks to fix it, too :-((
>

Ever the optimist.

--
Phil Kyle™
Uno
Dos
Tres
Cuatro
CINCO!!!!!!

"Be very aware that my willingness
to continue to criticise your sig
is infinite." -- Neil Barker

 

In article <MPG.1d926cb8c83a3dea98987c@127.0.0.1>, Neil Barker
<> wrote:

> In article <140920051329071193%>, says...
> > Anybody come across this before. The lens is quiet enough on a short
> > adjustment of the AF, but if focussing from, say, close up to infinity
> > then I can hear a nasty whine. It's especially pronounced when hunting
> > for focus and the motor is changing direction. Only had it a month,
> > and didn't notice it at first, but having not used it for a while, the
> > noise is now there and wouldn't seem normal for "Silent Wave". Also
> > this is the first AF-S Nikkor I've had so don't know if it's typical.
>
> No, it's certainly not normal for AF-S lenses. I've got 3 of them and
> none of them make that kind of noise - in use they are totally silent.
>
> But then again, it's a Nikon lens and with their quality control
> recently, anything's possible. And if you're planning on having it
> repaired, look forward to Nikon taking bloody weeks to fix it, too :-((

Thanks - I'll speak to the dealer. Wondering if it's due to being too
long in a hot car boot during the summer and the lubrication has been
affected. Hopefully I'll get it replaced...

 

Neil Barker wrote:
> In article <140920051329071193%>, says...
> > Anybody come across this before. The lens is quiet enough on a short
> > adjustment of the AF, but if focussing from, say, close up to infinity
> > then I can hear a nasty whine. It's especially pronounced when hunting
> > for focus and the motor is changing direction. Only had it a month,
> > and didn't notice it at first, but having not used it for a while, the
> > noise is now there and wouldn't seem normal for "Silent Wave". Also
> > this is the first AF-S Nikkor I've had so don't know if it's typical.
>
> No, it's certainly not normal for AF-S lenses. I've got 3 of them and
> none of them make that kind of noise - in use they are totally silent.
>
> But then again, it's a Nikon lens and with their quality control
> recently, anything's possible. And if you're planning on having it
> repaired, look forward to Nikon taking bloody weeks to fix it, too :-((

Damn it, there's that nasty whine again!

 

In article <>,
says...

(Nothing of worth)

Still being a fuckwit are we Joe ?

Copying your cronies now are we, stalking me via Google groops ?

How sad.

--
Neil Barker

 

Please don't reply to him, Neil. He's nearly trashed this ng as it is.
"Neil Barker" <> wrote in message
news:MPG.1d952c25dc0f929f98987e@127.0.0.1...
> In article <>,
> says...
>
> (Nothing of worth)
>
> Still being a fuckwit are we Joe ?
>
> Copying your cronies now are we, stalking me via Google groops ?
>
> How sad.
>
> --
> Neil Barker

 

In article <dggrbp$2ot$-infra.bt.com>,
says...

> Please don't reply to him, Neil. He's nearly trashed this ng as it is.

Oh, believe me, I won't be giving that fuckwith the time of day
anymore. He's a grade one arsehole and nothing else.

--
Neil Barker

 

Neil Barker wrote:
> In article <>,
> says...
>
> (Nothing of worth)

Surely I'm in your killfile?

 

whining noise

My 17-35 sometimes makes this whining noise as well. Otherwise it works perfect. I bought it second hand but it's still on seller's warranty. I don't know whether I should bother sending it back...