Upgrading Analog to Digital - Advice needed!

Discussion in 'Amateur Video Production' started by Betty, Jul 13, 2003.

  1. Betty

    Betty Guest

    If I copy my analog tapes from my analog camcorder to a digital
    camcorder, are the resulting tapes apt to be better quality because
    they are now digital?

    And if so, since I do not have either the iLink patch cord or a
    firewire on my computer, can I run the tape through my Dazzle capture
    gizmo to my computer and retain the better quality?

    I know the cliche: garbage in, garbage out. But have read that
    digitizing the analog tape via a good convertor can improve the
    quality somewhat. And have read that the Sony camcorder with the
    capability of converting the analog is superior to normal capture
    cards.

    Soooooooo! Original question, copying analog to digital using Sony
    camcorder, then capturing using Dazzle gizmo to computer......will I
    see an improvement? Or is it a waste of time and effort?

    I will be trying it when I get an opportunity. But curious as to what
    the general consensus is.

    Thanks.

    B............
     
    Betty, Jul 13, 2003
    #1
    1. Advertisements

  2. Betty

    Pete D Guest

    Betty,

    What is likely to happen is that capturing DV will throw away less of the
    original data. Capturing with analogue is always a balance of data rate
    versus acceptible quality, full analogue rate is something over 20 Mbps, DV
    at 3.6 Mbps will look very similar to full stream analogue.

    When I view my 11 year old tapes through my D8 camcorder they get digitised
    to DV and I bring them in via Firewire, they look at least as good as I
    played them 11 years ago.

    So I guess the answer "may" be that you "may" see an improvement!!! The best
    result will happen when you use a Hi8 or 8mm tape in a D8 camcorder, you may
    get almost as good a result if you use the S-Video connector from device to
    device.

    You will have to try for yourself and see!

    Cheers.
     
    Pete D, Jul 14, 2003
    #2
    1. Advertisements

  3. Betty

    Andrew Guest

    You can't gain any information that isnt already there. So technically, it
    can't really improve.

    BUT, it wont deteriorate as it would as analogue so converting to digital is
    a good idea.
     
    Andrew, Jul 14, 2003
    #3
  4. Quality will NEVER improve for the situation you described.
    You goal is to minimize quality loss during digital conversion.
    Most pass thru's from camcorders will have higher quality loss
    than using a good convertor like Canopus's Advc1000

    Buying the best digital camera that you can afford, along with proper
    lighting
    and a little experience is the best way to max out quality of digital video.
     
    Nobody_of_Consequence, Jul 14, 2003
    #4
    1. Advertisements

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments (here). After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.